“Your Honor, throughout this hearing I have stayed focused on what I personally know and what is physically possible. I have never watched the petitioner or her family. From my side, I only ever saw light through her window, not people or activity. The petitioner’s claims rely on assumptions about what I ‘might’ have been seeing, but no one can testify to what was in my line of sight.

Her photos do not show the conditions she describes, and several do not even show the window. The witnesses she presented cannot recall dates or times, and they cannot say what I was looking at. They also have a history of disagreements with me, which affects their neutrality.

There are no police reports, no landlord complaints, and no documentation supporting her allegations. The physical layout, the window height, the decorations, and the lighting all make her claims unlikely. The evidence presented does not meet the standard needed for a protection order.